My Super Bowl Ad Picks

The Super Bowl is, in comparison, the British Television Advertising Awards for the U.S. It has historically held some of the best advertising in the current market.

I would agree with the common sentiment that this year, due to the economic climate and waning interest, the ads didn't live up to the usual glory; but, there were still none the less some gems in the mix. Here are my picks for the 2010 Super Bowl:

1. Dove: Journey to Comfort/////Ogilvy

Although I felt the voice over was a little off, it had a relatively original, funny approach to selling a men's skin care product without making men appear to be unintelligent. I also love the reference to the scene in A Clockwork Orange with the use of music, content and cuts.

2. Cars.com: With Knowledge Comes Confidence/////DDB Chicago

Rarely does a serious ad seem to hit the mark on the Super Bowl; but, this in one of two that really did. It wasn't too preachy and had just enough dry humor to make it memorable. The best part though, it drove home it's main selling point, be confident with the knowledge you get from cars.com.

3. Google: Paris/////???

Again I was surprised with how memorable this simple ad was. It was one of the more innovative concepts, to tell a story through a simple search box and it seemed to target the 40% of female viewers that most ads ignored or openly offended.

4. Motorola: Megan Fox/////Anomaly

Although most ads featuring a half naked woman tend to be mindless and forget to talk about the product, this is one of the rare few that was very funny, sexy and left you with a clear idea of the product motorola blur.

5. Intel: Jeffrey the Robot/////Venables Bell & Partners

The first sweet and funny ad I've seen that is part of the larger excellent re-branding efforts of intel (putting faces to the name). I also feel that this is another great ad that was talking to the 40% of female viewers that most of the ads ignored.

/////

Worst Ad of the Super Bowl

Boost Mobile: Shuffle Dance/////180 Los Angeles

I would have to say this ad was terrible from the post production of trying to make it look dated, to the terrible copywriting and finally the horrible editing that destroyed the jokes. The worst part, everyone was so distracted with what was going on that they completely missed the message of the Boost Mobile's cheap rates.

/////

Best Social Media Ads

Brand Bowl///// Mullen & Radian 6

The sixth highest trending topic on twitter and a great way to stay on top of the winners on twitter in real time.

Squawq/////Colle+McVoy

Beautifully designed and a great analysis of the brand winners on all of twitter.

That wraps up the 2010 Super Bowl Ads. The biggest surprise this year, for me, was how memorable and well done the serious ads were over the funny ones.

Headin' to Arkansas

If an ad agency makes a great ad; but, it's hitting the wrong target is it really that bad?

I think thats a question that hangs in the air whenever an advertisement seems to be off key from a brand perspective. Of course, being way out of left field, hitting the wrong gender, race and age all at once would be too far off and would most likely dilute the brand by sending out too many and contradictory messages. However, how close to brand is too "close to brand."

When a client is obsessing where the toys came from, be it Target or Wal-Mart (which is the same exact toy), in a kid's fast food ad because their target consume is considered a wal-mart-like shopper. Is that going too far and isn't that obsessing too much over details that could detract from the big picture?

The subject came up when discussing the new memorable Caribou Coffee ads on youtube made by Colle + McVoy. The ads have a sometimes violent or disgusting sense of humor that feels more apt for a teenager and yet their audience tends to be middle aged, stay at home mom's.

You be the judge:

Caribou's "The Autumn Adventure of Jack & Gourdo #5"

Agency: Colle + McVoy

Reason: A well-made, dry sense of humor that plays with boundaries of acceptability; but, may be off the key consumer.

On a side note: I am happy to report that after being unemployed for a total of 12 day (8 work days), I received a job offer from an excellent, quickly growing agency Rockfish Interactive. They not only create great websites, innovative back-end tools, iPhone apps and social media tools; but, they also launch brands and were named "Best Small Agency of the Year" by Ad Age.

So I will be heading out on a road trip to Arkansas to check out the state and the agency in person. Look for posts on Thursday of traveling pics. . . y'all (thought I'd get started on my accent conversion).